7500 Island Cove Terrace

Sarasota, FL 34240

Our Name

Nimble isn’t just our name – it’s our philosophy.

We understand that every multifamily real estate venture is unique and believe that your commercial insurance coverage should be too. 

Our Mission

Our team is dedicated to a dynamic approach to multi family real estate insurance. We don’t believe in one-size-fits-all solutions.

Instead, we take the time to understand your investment intimately.

This fresh approach, infused with years of industry experience, allows us to navigate the complex world of insurance on your behalf and meticulously craft a custom policy so you only pay for what you need.

Why Choose Us

We are a modern commercial insurance firm built for Multifamily real estate owners and operators. We deliver tailored coverage, proactive risk management, and white-glove service so clients can protect their properties and focus on growth. Backed by deep real estate expertise, Nimble combines people-first service with smart insurance solutions that move as fast as your business.

“We recently transitioned our multifamily portfolio to Nimble Insurance and couldn’t be happier with the decision. Their team has been consistently responsive to our needs, offering competitive rates without compromising on coverage. What really sets Nimble apart is their people—they’re knowledgeable, professional, and genuinely easy to work with. They’ve made managing our insurance needs straightforward and stress-free. I’d recommend them to any property owner looking for a reliable insurance partner.”

-Nicholas Ameluxen

Chief Operating Officer of Quantum Capital

Our Team

Matthew Sutika

Owner / CEO
email

Dominick Lemme

Vice President of Operations
email

Sean Lanning

Vice President of Account Expansion and Retention
email

Nick Zott

Vice President of Client Relations
email

Sarah Gandy

Chief of Staff
email

David Dail

Vice President of Accounting and Finance
email

Joseph Sutika

Vice President of Sales
email

Ryan Lanning

Vice President of Account Expansion
email

Sarah Stewart

Manager of Client Success & Services
email

Zack Sutika

Manager of Client Success & Services
email

Jamison Gray

Director of Business Development
email

Chanel Compton

Manager of Client Success & Services
email

Lukas Mason

Manager of Account Expansion
email

Nem Natuno

Client Success & Services
email

Shaveta Gill

Accounting & Finance
email

get nimble.

Request a custom estimate today. A member of our team will follow up with you shortly.

We're So Excited For You To Get Nimble

Request a custom estimate today. A member of our team will follow up with you shortly.